Strategy
Strategy
Stop Spreading Your Marketing Budget Like Peanut Butter: Why FIs Fail Without Prioritization
Stop Spreading Your Marketing Budget Like Peanut Butter: Why FIs Fail Without Prioritization
Brian Knollenberg
Strategic Advisor
Favorite
Brian Knollenberg
Strategic Advisor
Favorite
Planning season is here, and C-Suite leaders are closing in on budget submissions.
If you sit in the executive suite of a mid-sized financial institution, you know the drill. The head of credit cards wants a Q1 acquisition campaign. The mortgage team demands extra ad spend to fight rate shifts and grow HELOCs. The deposit team points at liquidity ratios and demands immediate campaigns for high-yield savings and checking. Simple, right?
To each business line leader, their product is the center of the universe. They have dedicated teams, specific growth targets, and a laser focus on their own success metrics. And they demand marketing resource prioritization.
When marketing acts as a reactive order-taker, trying to satisfy every leader by spreading budget evenly, the result is predictable: disconnected tactics, cross-selling vs. tailored solutions, lower engagement, weak ROI, and diluted performance. And no clarity or metrics about how the marketing budget drives growth.
"He who defends everything, defends nothing."— Frederick the Great
Promoting every product line at once means promoting nothing effectively. While traditional marketing relies on the four Ps (Product, Price, Place, Promotion), strategic marketing performance requires a critical fifth P: Prioritization.
The High Cost of Reactive Order-Taking
In many banks and credit unions, marketing dollars flow to internal politics rather than strategic opportunity and member-driven need. A less-competitive product with high friction or weak margins gets a major campaign simply because an internal team demands support.
This creates two major risks for institutional growth:
Starved Growth Engines: True high-margin, core deposit, mobile banking, and profitable loan growth drivers get underfunded.
Fragmented Growth: Prospects and members face disjointed weekly product pitches—rather than a clear, personalized, relationship-building journey.
Aligning the 5th P with Executive KPIs
Prioritization is not about playing favorites. It is an analytical discipline that connects marketing spend directly to organizational key performance indicators. Before allocating a single dollar to promotional marketing, executive leaders must stress-test products against realistic benchmarks, consumer-driven insights, and clear performance metrics:
Product Usability: Fix friction first. If digital checking account onboarding takes 15 minutes or requires a branch visit, ad spend is wasted. Prioritize products with low-friction digital account opening.
Price and Margin: Protect the balance sheet. Direct capital toward products that drive net interest margin, core deposit growth, better engagement, or high-value credit card activations. Low-margin products move to the bottom of the active spend list.
Place and Precision: Target local density. Stop competing on price regionally or nationally (if you are). Shift budget into targeted digital and social channels where your local footprint and audience segmented data give you a distinct acquisition edge.
Moving to the Table of Results
Gaining C-Suite buy-in during budget season requires shifting the conversation from marketing costs to return on investment. Marketing must evolve from an internal service bureau into a strategic partner that helps set the growth agenda.
Rather than arguing over individual campaign requests throughout the year, establish three clear budget tiers during annual planning with executive leadership and product managers to drive business goals:
Tier 1 (Core Growth Drivers): Multi-channel, full-funnel digital and paid media campaigns tied directly to primary financial relationship growth targets.
Tier 2 (Targeted Support): Highly segmented digital campaigns triggered by specific member and prospect behaviors driving acquisition and wallet share.
Tier 3 (Baseline Operations): Organic web placement, branch collateral, and baseline digital presence with limited paid ad spend to increase engagement and performance.
When marketing decisions tie directly to top level organizational KPIs, saying no to disconnected requests becomes a data-driven business decision rather than a siloed political debate.
The Bottom Line
When everything is a priority, nothing is.
As you finalize plans for 2027, step back from the tactical noise of execution. Winning market share requires the courage, data insights, and executive alignment to do less, concentrating capital and marketing resources where it moves the balance sheet and improves member engagement.
Planning season is here, and C-Suite leaders are closing in on budget submissions.
If you sit in the executive suite of a mid-sized financial institution, you know the drill. The head of credit cards wants a Q1 acquisition campaign. The mortgage team demands extra ad spend to fight rate shifts and grow HELOCs. The deposit team points at liquidity ratios and demands immediate campaigns for high-yield savings and checking. Simple, right?
To each business line leader, their product is the center of the universe. They have dedicated teams, specific growth targets, and a laser focus on their own success metrics. And they demand marketing resource prioritization.
When marketing acts as a reactive order-taker, trying to satisfy every leader by spreading budget evenly, the result is predictable: disconnected tactics, cross-selling vs. tailored solutions, lower engagement, weak ROI, and diluted performance. And no clarity or metrics about how the marketing budget drives growth.
"He who defends everything, defends nothing."— Frederick the Great
Promoting every product line at once means promoting nothing effectively. While traditional marketing relies on the four Ps (Product, Price, Place, Promotion), strategic marketing performance requires a critical fifth P: Prioritization.
The High Cost of Reactive Order-Taking
In many banks and credit unions, marketing dollars flow to internal politics rather than strategic opportunity and member-driven need. A less-competitive product with high friction or weak margins gets a major campaign simply because an internal team demands support.
This creates two major risks for institutional growth:
Starved Growth Engines: True high-margin, core deposit, mobile banking, and profitable loan growth drivers get underfunded.
Fragmented Growth: Prospects and members face disjointed weekly product pitches—rather than a clear, personalized, relationship-building journey.
Aligning the 5th P with Executive KPIs
Prioritization is not about playing favorites. It is an analytical discipline that connects marketing spend directly to organizational key performance indicators. Before allocating a single dollar to promotional marketing, executive leaders must stress-test products against realistic benchmarks, consumer-driven insights, and clear performance metrics:
Product Usability: Fix friction first. If digital checking account onboarding takes 15 minutes or requires a branch visit, ad spend is wasted. Prioritize products with low-friction digital account opening.
Price and Margin: Protect the balance sheet. Direct capital toward products that drive net interest margin, core deposit growth, better engagement, or high-value credit card activations. Low-margin products move to the bottom of the active spend list.
Place and Precision: Target local density. Stop competing on price regionally or nationally (if you are). Shift budget into targeted digital and social channels where your local footprint and audience segmented data give you a distinct acquisition edge.
Moving to the Table of Results
Gaining C-Suite buy-in during budget season requires shifting the conversation from marketing costs to return on investment. Marketing must evolve from an internal service bureau into a strategic partner that helps set the growth agenda.
Rather than arguing over individual campaign requests throughout the year, establish three clear budget tiers during annual planning with executive leadership and product managers to drive business goals:
Tier 1 (Core Growth Drivers): Multi-channel, full-funnel digital and paid media campaigns tied directly to primary financial relationship growth targets.
Tier 2 (Targeted Support): Highly segmented digital campaigns triggered by specific member and prospect behaviors driving acquisition and wallet share.
Tier 3 (Baseline Operations): Organic web placement, branch collateral, and baseline digital presence with limited paid ad spend to increase engagement and performance.
When marketing decisions tie directly to top level organizational KPIs, saying no to disconnected requests becomes a data-driven business decision rather than a siloed political debate.
The Bottom Line
When everything is a priority, nothing is.
As you finalize plans for 2027, step back from the tactical noise of execution. Winning market share requires the courage, data insights, and executive alignment to do less, concentrating capital and marketing resources where it moves the balance sheet and improves member engagement.
Brian brings 25+ years of marketing leadership experience, helping financial institutions align strategy, strengthen member relationships, and drive measurable, sustainable growth.
More to Explore
More to Explore
